Mish's Global Economic Trend Analysis |
- Calpers Wins Pension Lawsuit, Not Good News for Chicago (or Bondholders in General)
- Blog Comments Down
- Dismal Retail Sales Numbers Suggest Recession Likely Underway: Overall +0.0%, YoY +0.9%, Department Stores -2.2%
Calpers Wins Pension Lawsuit, Not Good News for Chicago (or Bondholders in General) Posted: 13 May 2015 01:34 PM PDT Judge Rejects Bondholders' Lawsuit Over Pension Debt In bankruptcy, the federal courts have ruled that cities can reduce pension obligations. They can, but they don't have to. In Detroit, bondholders were sacrificed to maintain police and fire pensions with minimal haircuts. On Monday, U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Meredith Jury ruled against bondholders in favor of Calpers in the San Bernardino bankruptcy. She acknowledged that her decision is likely to be seen as unfair to the municipal bond market and might even discourage investors from buying pension obligation bonds in the future. Please consider Calpers' Pension Hammer Forces 'Unfair' Bond Ruling by Judge. California's public retirement fund holds so much power over local officials that pension-bond investors can't expect equal treatment when a city goes bankrupt, a judge said in a ruling that she acknowledged seems "unfair."Up to Cities Federal bankruptcy courts have many times ruled that cities can cut pension obligation, but nothing forces them to. For example, in the Stockton California bankruptcy, a federal judge ruled that Stockton could have tried to reduce its obligation to Calpers. However, Stockton chose not to do so, arguing that fighting Calpers would take too long and could endanger employee pensions. Conflict of Interest I believe Stockton's rationale is nonsense. Instead, I propose Stockton city officials had a conflict of interest. City officials wanted to preserve their own pensions. Chicago Connection So what does this have to do with Chicago and the state of Illinois in general? Lots, so let's tie it all together. As a result Tuesday's Illinois Supreme Court Ruling that the 2013 Pension Reform Law Is Unconstitutional Moody's cut Chicago's bond rating two notches to junk. Moody's specifically cited Chicago's pension crisis. I discussed this yesterday in Chicago Bond Rating Cut to Junk; City Faces $2.2 Billion in Various Termination Fees; Irresponsible to Tell the Truth. In light of the San Bernardino ruling today, cities that have huge pension issues will see bond yields soar. The Chicago Board of education is already paying 285 basis points more than other cities because of pensions. If bondholders keep getting hammered, those yields will rise further. Pass a Bankruptcy Law, Give Taxpayers a Chance A Chicago Tribune editorial by Henry J. Feinberg, says Pass a Bankruptcy Law, Give Taxpayers a Chance. Under federal law, state governments can't file for bankruptcy. Local governments can do so if their states give them permission. A bill now before the Illinois legislature would extend that permission to Illinois municipalities, most of which now can't seek protection under bankruptcy law. The right way is to amend House Bill 298 so people who hold Illinois bonds have a "secured first lien," the fancy words needed in the law to make sure bondholders are first in line to get their money back. Passing this amended bill would do three things that the state's local governments have not been able to accomplish for decades. Three Reasons to Amend Bill 298 Feinberg cites three reasons to amend the pending bankruptcy bill.
I agree with Feinberg on all three points. Bankruptcy is the only real solution for many of these plans and many cities as well. Beware the Tax Man Tax hikes cannot possibly address the shortfall. As discussed on May 4, in Beware, the Tax Man Has Eyes on You, the potential hike for Illinoisans is staggering. Nuveen estimated 50% property tax hikes would be necessary. Those hikes were just for Chicago. They did not include money to bail out other Illinois pension plans. Nor did it address the $9 billion budget deficit for the state. Finally, Nuveen's estimate assumed pension plans would make their plan assumption of 7% returns or higher. Stock Market Bubble Will Hit Pensions I believe another serious decline in the stock market is likely. So do some of the biggest fund managers in the world. Please check out Seven Year Negative Returns in Stocks and Bonds; Fraudulent Promises. Pension promises were not made in good faith. Rather, pension promises were the direct result of coercion by public unions on legislators, mayors, and other officials willing to accept bribes because they shared in the ill-gotten gains of backroom deals at taxpayer expense. Illinois taxpayers cannot be held accountable for coercion of public officials by public unions. Mike "Mish" Shedlock http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com |
Posted: 13 May 2015 10:52 AM PDT I have posted on this before, but many people missed it. JS-Kit/Echo went under. Along with that development, the comment system on this blog no longer works. I am looking for a replacement but have not been able to get Disqus to work. I also need to strip out all of the Echo code, but have not done so because some of it I may need to handle peculiarities of this blog. If someone is familiar with Disqus and blogger and is free to help, I would appreciate it. Thanks. Mike "Mish" Shedlock http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com |
Posted: 13 May 2015 09:10 AM PDT Economists were surprised by the dismal retail sales report this morning. That's not surprising because economists are nearly always surprised. The Bloomberg Consensus retail sales estimate was a rise of 0.2%, but sales came in at 0.0% and the details were ugly, emphasis mine. Consumer confidence may be strong but it still is not translating to strength for consumer spending. Retail sales were unchanged in April vs Econoday expectations for a 0.2 percent gain. Excluding autos, sales did rise but only barely at plus 0.1 and below expectations for 0.5 percent, while excluding both autos and gasoline, sales rose 0.2 percent vs expectations for a 0.4 percent gain.Estimated Retail Sales The Census Department offers this Table of Retail Sales. click on chart for sharper image Note the huge patch of negative numbers this month. At least people are still eating out and drinking more. Also note the negative numbers in the November 2014 through January 2015 column. Economists expected the decline in gasoline sales (down 7.2%) to translate into increased sales elsewhere. It didn't. I am scratching my head over Bloomberg's statement "consumer confidence may be strong ...". What the heck is Bloomberg talking about? Does Bloomberg even read its own numbers? Here is a snip from the Bloomberg Consumer Confidence Level Report for April 2015, released on 4/28/2015. Consumer confidence has fallen back noticeably this month, down more than 6 points to a much lower-than-expected 95.2. This compares very poorly with the Econoday consensus for 103.0 and is even far below the Econoday low estimate of 100.5. The weakness, ominously, is the result of falling assessments of the jobs market, both the current jobs market and expectations for the future jobs market. The second quarter, which is expected to be much stronger than the weather-depressed first quarter, isn't likely to get off to a fast start, at least as far as this report goes.The Fed is not looking at those numbers either. In the latest FOMC report the Fed specifically stated "consumer sentiment remains high". I mocked the Fed on April 29 in Fed Cites Weather, "Transitory" Factors in FOMC Statement; What About Consumer Sentiment? Autos Only Reason YoY Sales Are Positive Autos are now the only thing keeping retail sales positive year-over-year. And auto sales are driven by subprime loans. How long is this party going to last? Who wants a car, needs a car, can afford a car, and can get a car loan? Retail Sales Flashbacks
Household Spending Growth Expectations Plunge; Recession Already Started? Every month the Fed does a Survey of Consumer Expectations for inflation, earnings growth, income growth, and consumer spending growth. Yesterday, I stuck my neck out regarding consumer spending projections: Household Spending Growth Expectations Plunge; Recession Already Started? Downloading data from the Fed, I produced this chart. click on chart for sharper image This is what I said yesterday... Spending AnalysisThe Fed's own survey shows spending sentiment is weak. The data shows how weak. Amusingly, the Fed says "consumer sentiment remains high". And Bloomberg does not believe its own sentiment numbers either. Following today's report, I move my position from a recession may have started to a recession is now likely underway. I suspect economists and the Fed will still believe it's "transitory". If so, look for the term "technical recession" because no one seems to believe it. Heck, they do not even believe their own data. Mike "Mish" Shedlock http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com |
You are subscribed to email updates from Mish's Global Economic Trend Analysis To stop receiving these emails, you may unsubscribe now. | Email delivery powered by Google |
Google Inc., 1600 Amphitheatre Parkway, Mountain View, CA 94043, United States |