Mish's Global Economic Trend Analysis |
Greece Played Germany Like a Violin; Horrified Syriza Demands 'Icelandic' Default Posted: 16 Jun 2015 01:48 PM PDT A time-based analysis of eurozone taxpayer liabilities shows the Greek game-masters played German creditors like a violin. What got me thinking about this in detail was a recent statement by Financial Times writer Wolfgang Münchau that France and Germany stand to forfeit €160 billion if Greece defaults. On January 22, I had French exposure at €55 billion and German exposure at €73 billion, a total of €128 billion. See Revised Greek Default Scenario: Liabilities Shifted to German and French Taxpayers; Bluff of the Day Revisited The difference between our numbers is almost all due to a huge jump in Target2 imbalances. Let's take a look. Partial Table of Liabilities January 22
The above table derived from Exposure of European Countries to Greece by Dr. Eric Dor, IESEG School of management. The total does not add up because I included only France, Germany, Italy, and Spain. Partial Table of Liabilities March 4
On March 4, the taxpayer liability of France and Germany increased to approximately €145 billion. The liability of the "big four" jumped from €209 billion to €239 billion. Target2 Now Yesterday, reader Lars from Norway pinged me with these thoughts. Hello MishMath at €118 Billion At the best case scenario (not counting additional cash under the mattress by Greek citizens), Target2 is a minimum of €118 billion. Assuming the other numbers don't change much (the first two columns shouldn't change at all) the math looks something like this.
I took the IESEG numbers and plugged in €118 billion as a total Target2 liability, split as shown. Germany and France total liability by this calculation is about €167 billion, a number very close to Wolfgang Münchau's calculation of €160 billion, and up from approximately €128 billion at the end of January. The "big four" liability is now about €273 billion. Can someone, anyone tell me where Italy can or will come up with €63 billion or Spain with €43 billion? Loaded Gun Question Previously I asked "Who has the loaded gun and who doesn't?" "If Greece is smart, it will not implement capital controls until the ECB shuts down the ELA, forcing the issue. Greece will then have the ECB and Germany to blame for the resultant controls." Traditional analysis failed miserably. Nearly all, if not all of mainstream media, thought the creditors had the upper hand. Quoting Bob Dylan I said "When you ain't got nothing, you got nothing to lose" (See "Air of Unreality"; "Do You Feel Lucky, Punk?"; Who Has the Gun?) Germany Still Trapped The only way Germany can stop Target2 from rising further is to shut off the ELA. The moment it does so, the ECB or Germany gets the blame. In situations like these, the sooner you take the punishment the better. But here we are, with increased capital flight every day. Germans can and will point the finger for this one at Angela Merkel, yet another victory for Greece. Horrified Syriza Demands 'Icelandic' Default Today we learn the EU is calling an emergency meeting. Good luck with that. There's nothing they can do at this point. Didn't they say just yesterday the ball in in Greece's court? Today we also learned the Syriza Left Demands 'Icelandic' Default as Defiance Stiffens. The radical wing of Greece's Syriza party is to table plans over coming days for an Icelandic-style default and a nationalisation of the Greek banking system, deeming it pointless to continue talks with Europe's creditor powers.Central Bank Arrogance Recall the statement: "There is No Plan B"? Let's go back much further. Does anyone even recall the start of this nonsense? Of course, it goes back to the creation of the eurozone in the first place. A monetary union without a fiscal union is inevitably going to break apart. And the eurozone never should have admitted Greece in the first place. But I am referring to statements by prior ECB president Jean-Claude Trichet regarding no haircuts and no defaults. Here is a small snip from my July 7, 2011 article Trichet Says "No" to Selective Default. The ECB has proved a major stumbling block in agreeing a second rescue plan for Greece as it has threatened to refuse restructured Greek bonds as collateral in its lending operations in the event of a default or a "restricted default," which ratings agencies are threatening to impose.I responded "Trichet can shout 'no default' from the mountain tops but it is not his call to make." Trichet Ballistic Over Term "Soft Restructuring" On May 19, 2011 I noted Trichet Goes Ballistic, Walks Out of Meeting Over the Term "Soft Restructuring" Prior to that Trichet said numerous times there would be "no haircuts" on Greek debt. Here we are, two major bailouts accompanied with haircuts later. Along the way, eurozone nannycrats and the ECB turned a minor problem into a €330 billion problem. The arrogance of central bankers who believe they can control markets with talk is stunning. Neither the ECB nor the eurozone nannycrats is in control of this situation. They don't have a loaded gun, and are not in any position to make demands. I am curious how much longer it will take them to figure this out. I will accept as evidence they finally understand reality the moment the ECB shuts off the ELA. At least they are working on "Plan B". Turnabout Irony Note the irony of it all. Germany wanted to issue a "Take it or leave it proposal to Greece". Instead we see Greece issuing a "Restructure or we leave proposal to Germany". It's likely this was Syriza's plan all along. If so, they managed to play Germany like a finely tuned violin, allowing Greek citizens to pull out cash out of banks every day for six months. Mike "Mish" Shedlock http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Posted: 16 Jun 2015 10:32 AM PDT Housing starts underperformed the Bloomberg Econoday Economists' Consensus Estimate enough for the Atlanta Fed GDPNow Forecast to give back the 0.1% it gained yesterday, yet the report is still considered "solid". Atlanta Fed Forecast Revised Lower I do not know what economists in general will do, but I do know that contrary to Bloomberg's prediction, the Atlanta Fed's GDPNow Forecast ticked down following today's report. Latest forecast — June 16, 2015Evolution of GDPNow Comparing both April and May to the abysmal March is as lame as it would be to label the decline today as overwhelming. If this is weather-related as economists insisted, then this is a weather-related snap-back as well. Which is it? Before anyone gets really excited by housing numbers, here is a bit of historical perspective. Housing Starts Historical Perspective At this level of starts, the economy was in recession a perfect seven times out of seven previously. And on a population adjusted basis, this number of starts is actually pathetic. Nonetheless, housing will still add to GDP as conditions are generally improving. Mike "Mish" Shedlock http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com |
You are subscribed to email updates from Mish's Global Economic Trend Analysis To stop receiving these emails, you may unsubscribe now. | Email delivery powered by Google |
Google Inc., 1600 Amphitheatre Parkway, Mountain View, CA 94043, United States |